See below for a list of claim phone numbers for each insurance company. Some carriers also offer online claim reporting. You can also call either of our offices to report your claim; we are here to help!

The Hartford
Personal Auto & Homeowners: 1-800-243-5860
DBL: 1-800-303-9744
Commercial Auto, Property, General Liability & Workers Comp: 1-800-327-3636
Website: https://www.thehartford.com/

Travelers
Phone: 800-252-4633
Website: https://www.travelers.com/


Hanover Insurance Group
Phone: 800-628-0250
Website: https://www.hanover.com/

Finger Lakes Fire & Casualty
Phone: 800-724-4032
Website: https://www.flfcc.com/index.cfm?

Erie & Niagara
Phone: 800-234-9876
Website: https://www.enia.com/

Dryden Mutual Insurance Co.
Phone: 800-782-0154
Website: https://drydenmutual.com/

Main Street America Group
Phone: 877-425-2467
Website: http://www.msagroup.com/

Foremost Insurance Group
For Foremost Policies: 800-435-7764
For Zurich Policies: 800-987-3373
Workers Compensation: 1-866-967-5256
Website: https://www.foremost.com/claims/

ShelterPoint
Formerly First Rehab Life
Pay: 877-425-2467
Email (for forms): 1-800-365-4999
Email (for questions): dbclaims@shelterpoint.com
Website: https://www.shelterpoint.com/insured/dblclaimguide.aspx?p=1.1.2.2

National General Insurance
Formerly GMAC
Phone: 1-800-325-1088
Website: http://www.itsallabouthotels.com/gmac123com/

Philadelphia Insurance Company
Phone: 1-800-765-9749
Website: https://www.phly.com/

Preferred Mutual
Phone: 1-800-333-7642
Website: https://www.preferredmutual.com/

Merchants Insurance Group
Phone: 800-952-5246
Website: https://www.merchantsgroup.com/claims-center/

Progressive
Phone: 1-800-274-4499
Website: https://www.progressive.com/


Sterling Insurance Company
Phone: 800-462-4661
Website: http://www.sterlingins.com/


MEMIC
Phone: 1-800-636-4292
Website: https://www.memic.com/employers/report-an-injury

NYCM Insurance
Also applies to A. Central Insurance policy holders
Phone: 800-234-6926
Website: https://www.nycm.com/claims/

Adirondack Insurance Exchange
Phone: 877-365-8693
Website: http://www.aie-ny.com/

Safeco Insurance
Phone: 800-332-3226
Website: https://www.safeco.com/claims